Valentine’s Day is so much fun and you can have an absolute blast coming up with cute ideas and matching witty sayings…and that’s what we’ve done for you today with our “O-FISH-ALLY” the Best Valentines free printable collection! What cute fish valentines.

three tags that say Im hooked on you valentine, you're such a great catch valentine

Related: Get ready for a classroom Valentine’s extravaganza! 50 printable Valentines with witty puns and clever sayings. These pun-tastic cards are perfect for spreading smiles on Valentine’s Day! 💌💕

These come together to make a cute Valentine’s gift for just about anyone!

valetine gift tags on white table with spools of twine

Classroom Valentines

If you’re a mom with little ones like me – you most likely have an overabundance of baked fish crackers in the pantry – so that makes for an expensive little treat (use what’s already on hand)!

you're such a great catch valentine tag attached to a bag of gold fish crackers

You’re Such a Great Catch, Valentine

I also got a little crafty and went for the big guns – Gummy Worms and Gummy Fish!

i'm hooked on you tag attached to a bag of gummy worms
I’m Hooked on You, Valentine

you're such a great catch valentine tag attached to gummy fish

Cute Fish Valentine

TIP: You can even use the printable to create mini cards instead of attaching them to treats. They would make cute little valentines all on their own – you just have to trim them to size and they would fit perfectly into a coin-sized envelope.

valentine gift tag with coin envelopes

valentine tag with colorful coin envelopes

Fish Valentine Sayings

Fish Themed Valentine Sayings

It was so much fun putting together these puntastic sayings that were “quite fishy” –

  • “I’m hooked on you, Valentine!”
  • “You’re such a great catch, Valentine!”
  • “You’ve got me hook, line and sinker, Valentine!” 
  • “You’re O-Fish-ally the Best Valentine!”

With this free printable…you get a full sheet of each saying!

printed tags, spools of twine, swedish fish, goldfish crackers, gummy worms
Printable Valentine Supplies

What You Need:

Supplies we used:

  • Glossy Sticker Paper from Online Labels
  • Canon Matte Photo Paper (found at most office supply stores)
  • Clear Cello Bags from Garnish
  • Clear Pillow Boxes from SRM Stickers
  • Baby Envelopes from Paper Source (colors: red, fuchsia, poppy & pool)
  • Baker’s Twine
  • Treats: Gummy Worms, Gummy Fish & Baked Fish Crackers
  • “O-FISH-ALLY” the Best Valentines free printable collection!
step by step photos of printed tags, cutting tags, punching tags

How to Make O-fish-ally the Best Valentines

How to Make

Here’s what you’ll need to do to create fun, fishy treats using our free printables:

1. Download our “O-Fish-ally” the Best Valentines printables HERE.

2. Save as a PDF file and Print the file. If you’re creating gift tags or mini cards, we highly recommend Matte Photo Paper (it’s thick like card stock, but it gives a really crisp image when printed). If you want to create stickers, we love glossy full-sheet sticker paper. Just make sure you choose the proper ‘paper type’ from your printer’s settings so you get the best finished product.

3. Cut the tags or stickers to your desired size. The best part about our printable…you can choose what size you’d like to use! Cut the full design for a gift tag…only cut out the ‘pennant’ shape in the middle for a smaller tag too!

4. For stringing your gift tags or wrapping little favors and treats, use colorful baker’s twine. We created these printables to match colorful bakers twine.

5. Grab your treats and supplies, then go to town!  Have fun!

These fishy Valentines were created by The Twinery Blog


More Cute Free Printable Valentines

I would love to keep you fully stocked with creative ideas, yummy recipes, fun crafts, and loads of free printables. Subscribe to Skip to my Lou to get new ideas delivered to your inbox. Follow me on Facebook, Pinterest, Twitter, and Instagram for all my latest updates.

About Cindy Hopper

Learn More

you may also like


  1. Hi, I know you posted this a LONG time ago, but the link is dead. Do you still have the pdf for this? I’m giving someone a crochet hook and yarn so the Hooked on You tag would be great but I can’t find any others. Thanks

  2. As a crafty Mom, and design team member at The Twinery, I LOVE these ideas. Can I admit…sometimes I run out of ideas and Nicole always creates fresh, fun crafts to share. My sweetheart is out of town until tomorrow, so I do believe I’ll be on the lookout for Swedish Fish…heading to download the printables now!

  3. As the DT Coordinator over at The Twinery, I am a bit biased, but I LOVE Nicole’s creativity & these projects are super-duper easy to make! Perfect Valentines for all ages!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *