Valentine Fortune Teller Surprise Me! Surprise your crush with a sweet valentine fortune from Draw! Pilgrim. Hi readers, my name is Pilgrim and I run Draw! Pilgrim papergoods. I’ve created this classic “cootie catcher” or fortune teller printable with candy hearts in mind (when don’t I have candy in mind)! Download the template and instructions here, then get folding! Has it been awhile since you’ve made a cootie catcher? Don’t miss all the other fun printable Valentines in our Print Your Valentine’s Series.