More Teacher Gift Ideas Surprise Me! If you are looking for teacher gifts you won’t want to miss these teacher appreciation ideas. You’ll also be inspired by these teacher gifts. 10 Terrific Teacher Gifts Vase made from colored pencils Etched Pencil and Pen Holders Hand Soap Featuring Children’s Artwork Monogrammed Hand Sanitizer Reusable Lunch Sack Homemade lanyard for badges and whistles Pretty Up Some Pens A great gift from the whole class, a giving tree. Jumbo Covered Button Paper Clips A Handmade Zippered Pouch makes a perfect gift card holder!